The Father of Modern Bonsai in Japan
This Page Last Updated: February 26, 2001
| Kyuzo
Murata was born in 1902 in Takayama City, Gifu Prefecture. He entered
Keio Gijuku University, Tokyo (some 140 miles to the southeast of his birthplace
and two miles south of the Imperial Palace), but had to leave without graduating
in order to receive treatment for a severe gastric ulcer.
On his doctor's advice, he then went about twenty miles northwest of the capital "to Omiya, where the water was reputed to have health-giving properties for humans as well as for miniature trees. Inevitably exposed to the profession practiced by several other residents, Murata tried his hand at it and presently found that he was blessed with a green thumb. He established his garden there in 1926." The acre and a half plot was called Kyuka-En, the Garden of the Nine Mists. 1 In
the late 1920s and early 1930s, Kyuzo Murata and his associates regularly
went to Furukamappu on Kunashiri Island (to the east of the big north Japanese
island of Hokkaido). This was the native home of the Ezo spruce (Picea
glehni). The place where they grew is called Yachi, a marshland
having a thick mass of accumulated sphagnum moss. This is an inhospitable
natural environment where the land is covered with deep snow from the middle
of September until the middle of May, a place where the wind blows endlessly.
Murata and company would pack up the trees they collected about the first
or second of September every year and ship them down to Honshu, Japan's
main island. The roots were packed in sphagnum moss, then wrapped
in burlap and tied with string. The trees were then placed in specially
constructed boxes for shipping. They would travel by rail and reach
Omiya by the tenth or eleventh of September. At the time of collecting
most only had one or two white living roots showing. By the time
they were transported, and despite the poor condition after they arrived,
they would have a profusion of vigorous white roots growing out through
the burlap.
Kyuzo Murata came to serve the Imperial Household in Tokyo in 1931, caring for their magnificent collection of bonsai. And he began to assist Masakuni I (Shichinosuke Kawasumi, 1880-1950) in developing additional tools for bonsai. A well-known manufacturer of flower arranging scissors and medical-use cutting tools, Masakuni in 1919 had established a company to carry Japanese bonsai tools. In the early 1920s he invented the first shears specifically designed for use on bonsai, and a little later came out with the epoch-making concave cutter. In 1938, Murata exhibited one of his early creations, a thirteen tree Ezo spruce group planting from collected material. 2 "[The
bonsai growers at Omiya] were just beginning to become prosperous again
[ -- most had resettled there from Tokyo two years after the great earthquake
of 1923 -- ] when World War II broke out. The draft and the emphasis
on raising foodstuffs reduced the number of Omiya growers from a peak of
twenty-three [families] in the late 1930s to one, Murata.
Immediately
after the Pacific War, the luxury tax on bonsai was so high that it nearly
caused the disbandment of the growers at Omiya.
From 1949 to 1955, Kyuzo Murata was chairman of the Nihon Bonsai Kumiai (Professional Bonsai Gardener's Association of Japan). He was often in contact with Toshiji Yoshimura, a prominent bonsai and suiseki artist from Tokyo. At one point, Mrs. Murata introduced a lovely young Omiya lady, Kazuko Nagano, to Toshiji's son, Yuji. On March 11, 1948 Yuji Yoshimura and Miss Magano were married. (Yoshimura would go on to make his mark in the bonsai world outside of Japan.) Murata was head between 1954 and 1960 of the Japan Union of Bonsai Growers, in which capacity he contributed greatly to the cause of the art. Mr. and Mrs. Edward Holsten, two of the Brooklyn Botanic Garden's Trustees, returned from a world cruise in 1958 having procured a number of superior specimens from some of Japan's finest bonsai nurseries. This collection of trees was finally imported in 1961. Mr. and Mrs. Howard Phipps, Sr., also traveling to Japan in the 1950s, brought back several trees to start the collection that bears their name. Most of the high-ranking specimens in both collections came from Murata's Kyuka-en. 5 Now,
Lynn Perry was a graduate of the Pennsylvania School of Horticulture for
Women, and also studied in the Dept. of Landscape Architecture of the University
of Pennsylvania. She became the first American to study bonsai with
a Japanese master for an extended period of time. For one or two
days a week from 1960 through the fall of 1962, she received instruction
from Murata. After intensive practical and theoretical training,
she was awarded a teaching certificate by her sensei. During this
time she wrote Bonsai: Trees and Shrubs, A Guide to the Methods of Kyuzo
Murata, which was published in 1964 by The Ronald Press. While
in Japan she also served as a member of the staff of the Agricultural Attaché
at the American Embassy in Tokyo.
Also in 1964, the English publication was made of Kyuzo Murata's Bonsai: Miniature Potted Trees by Tokyo's Shufunotomo Co., Ltd. (Its twenty-fourth printing would be made in 1986.) Seventeen
members of the Bonsai Society of Greater New York went to Japan in March
1967 to study for a week with Kyuzo Murata. The tour had taken a
year to plan and coordinate. The group, including Jerry Stowell,
Lynn Perry Alstadt, Marion Gyllenswan, George Hull, and Constance Derderian,
flew from San Francisco to Honolulu where they met with members of the
local clubs there, and then on to Omiya. On Sunday night the group
had dinner with Mr. Murata and his wife at the Japanese inn were the Americans
were staying. The next morning they walked through the
The following March, with most of his flowering trees in full but late bloom, Kyuzo Murata hosted for the first time an American Bonsai Society group to visit and study at Omiya. In attendance at Kyuka-en for the members of the New York area were Murata's colleague, Masakuni Kawasumi, and two of the former's best students, Masao Komatsu and Yasuji Matsuda. The cover b&w photograph of the Spring issue (Vol. 2, No. 1) of ABS' Bonsai Journal was of a 400-year old, 40-year-in-training Sargent juniper (Juniperus chinensis var. Sargentii) from Murata's nursery. The container was a gray, unglazed antique Chinese pot. 7 |
|
February and March of 1969 saw the second ABS tour of Japan, led by Lynn Alstadt and Jerry Stowell. After touring Takamatsu, Kyoto, and Nagoya, a five-day stay with Kyuzo Murata was further highlighted by visits to the nine other prominent bonsai nurseries in Omiya and the opportunity to see the prestigious annual Kokufu Bonsai Exhibition in Tokyo. 8 And a November issue of the New Yorker magazine mentioned the arrival of the celebrated three foot tall tree "Fudo" to the Brooklyn Botanic Garden. The page and a half long article was appropriately titled "Old Juniper." Considered to be between 600 and 1,000 years old, the tree was reportedly found in 1910 by the famous bonsai tree hunter Tahei Suzuki and was first wired by Kinsaku Saida, said to be the greatest wiring master of all time. Making its first public appearance in 1929, the bonsai received the first prize -- and promptly vanished. Its owner at the time was a Japanese oil magnate who was afraid that exhibitions would spoil the tree. A special place deep inside his mansion was built for the "Phantom Shimpaku" (as it would be called by people who saw the tree during its only exhibition). In 1946, having survived the war, the tree was purchased by Yoshimatsu Hattori and received the name of "Fudo." The name comes from the "God of Fire Fudo," an imaginary guardian of the Buddha against all evils, standing amid burning flame without moving. "Fudo's" appearance suggested swirling flames. Yoshimatsu Hatori died in 1960, and his entire bonsai collection was put up for sale, except "Fudo" which was taken by his son Osamu. Although Osamu was not keen about bonsai, it took Kyuzo Murata several years to persuade him to sell that particular tree. It was finally in the summer of 1969 that "Fudo" came to Murata at Kyuka-en, by which time not many people had actually seen the tree except in a photograph. Per Dr. George S. Avery, director of the BBG who was instrumental in introducing tens of thousands of Americans to bonsai and in developing the Garden's outstanding collection:
FUDO"Fudo" arrived in New York via Pan American Airways and was officially met at Kennedy International Airport by Robert S. Tomson, Assistant Director of the BBG, together with representatives of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. The prescribed fumigation treatment was carried out. "Fudo" was put on display at the BBG in a screened quarantine cage -- where she remained until release by the Plant Quarantine Division of the Department of Agriculture. This hardly seemed a fitting wedding reception for so distinguished a bride; yet it complied with plant importation law and was a justifiable precaution against the introduction of plant pests which, though perhaps no problem in their original homeland, might be difficult or impossible to control if they were to escape in a new environment. 9 In
October 1971, the fine shimpaku "Fudo" was declared dead. Her body
is still preserved at the BBG where it remains inspirational. Probably
the oldest living plant of any kind ever shipped to the U.S., it was said
to be about eight hundred and fifty years of age when it died after a year
here. A photograph taken in 1970 in Japan "shows the lower branch,
where all the trouble apparently began, not showing any visible change,
but the foliage on that branch was thinner than the rest of the foliage."
The September 1971 issue of Shizen To Bonsai (Nature and Bonsai) magazine contained an article by Murata regarding the early days of ezo spruce bonsai. (The article would be translated into English, edited and reprinted nineteen years later in International Bonsai magazine.) 11 In November, 1971 a Workshop and Study Tour of Japan took place, endorsed by the ABS. Lynn Perry Alstadt, Constance Derderian, George Hull, and Jerry Stowell led the tour which featured a four day seminar at Kyuzo Murata's Omiya garden. One year later, Luther and Dorothy Young led a trip with classes to Japan and Hong Kong. Visits were paid to Kyuzo Murata, Toshio Kawamoto, Wu Yee-sun, and other hosts and locales. 12 Murata visited the Brooklyn Botanic Garden where a gathering of 300 people heard his talk on the art of bonsai. Quoting from The New York Times, July 9, 1975: "Bonsai is the art of pruning and wiring branches and cutting roots which eventually result in controlling growth so that trees are trained to live in pots,' said Mr. Murata. Because Mr. Murata, a Zen Buddhist, believes that trees have feelings, he said it hurts them to be cut. 'But it has to be cut,' he continued, 'The tree must understand that I do it out of love -- it's like spanking my own children [sic].'" Murata and Kawasumi were the guest artists at both the BCI convention in Miami Beach, FL ("New Bonsai Horizons," running from July 2 through 6 and attended by 319 people) and the ABS convention in Kansas City, MO (held July 10 through 12). Murata's closing remarks to ABS following a wide-ranging overview of "my favorite and the only subject I have known all my life" were: "Again, I wish to emphasize that bonsai is not a mere sketch of nature but a reflection of the heart of the creator. Please create your own Americanized bonsai and fill the world with this peaceful art. Sayonara, I shall see you in Tokyo." 13 |
| The
visit was also a promotional tour for Kawasumi's new book, Bonsai with
American Trees (Tokyo: Kodansha International, Ltd.). Murata
had penned the Introduction to this work. (In 1971 Japan Publications,
Inc. had come out with Kawasumi's
Introductory Bonsai and the Care and
Use of Bonsai Tools. That volume was supervised by Murata.)
The biggest problem for sending bonsai abroad anywhere is the soil: every country prohibits soil of another country from being brought in due to microbial and larger pests. In the case of ordinary trees, the soil attached to the plant is completely removed and is subjected to strict examination. This would not do for fifty-three bonsai which were part of Japan's Bicentennial gift to the U.S. -- perhaps the lesson with "Fudo" was still fresh on everyone's mind. As an exceptional case, the U.S.D.A. decided that the bonsai together with pots would, instead, be carried to the National Nursery and subjected to quarantine and cultivation with help from Japan for one year. At the end of the period, quarantine would be finished. The Nippon Bonsai Association representatives were very pleased with these arrangements, saying that America not only recognized bonsai as Japan's traditional art, but also fully understood the trees themselves. The fact that all the gifted trees survived with this nonstandard treatment could be considered a nod to "Fudo." Kyuzo Murata contributed the Foreword to Jerald P. Stowell's 1978 book, The Beginner's Guide to American Bonsai (Tokyo: Kodansha International Ltd.). The following year, an Ezo spruce (Picea glehni) trained by Murata from collected material and in the sinuous style won an award at the Japan Bonsai Creator's Exhibition. 14 In 1984, Kyuzo Murata's book Bonsai no shiki was released. Four years later, the Japanese Ministry of Education awarded Kyuzo Murata the prestigious Order of the Rising Sun in recognition of his contribution to Japanese culture and society. He was the first bonsai gardener to receive this honor. 15 An
English translation and adaptation of Murata's last book was published
by Kodansha as Four Seasons of Bonsai in 1991.
"...I could not help but compare the bonsai of his early and later years
to the sculptures of Michelangelo in his early and later years. The
early works are superb, controlled, and perfected; the work done near life's
end, Murata's flowering material and Michelangelo's uncompleted studies,
in stone, of slaves in chains are less detailed. They are vital,
impressionistic studies of great power with an appearance of freshness
and spontaneity that belies the control we know guided the mature hands
of these masters.
A posthumous work, Bonsai, Nature in Miniature, was published by Shufunotomo Ltd. in the year 2000. The co-author is listed as Isamu Murata, sensei's son who was born in 1936 and began studying bonsai himself in 1959. After Kyuzo's death, Isamu took over the running of Kyoka-en. 18 |
| 1 Murata, Kyuzo
Bonsai:
Miniature Potted Trees (Tokyo: Shufunotomo Co., Ltd., 1964), pg. 115;
Busch, Noel F., "The Lilliputian World of the Bonsai", The Reader's
Digest, September 1967, pg. 184.
2 Murata, Kyuzo "The Early Days of Ezo Spruce Bonsai," International Bonsai, International Bonsai Arboretum, 1990/No. 2, pp. 14-17, pg. 15 with b&w photo of the group planting; Tayson, Dr. Juyne, "Bonsai Personality -- Kyuzo Murata" , International Bonsai Digest Bicentennial Edition (Los Angeles: International Bonsai Digest, 1976), pg. 94; Nozaki, Shinobu Dwarf Trees (Bonsai) (Tokyo: Sanseido Company, Ltd., 1940), pg. 34; Masakuni's Bonsai Tools and User's Manual (1979, seventh edition 1989), inside front cover and pg. 5. How did Murata come to care for the Imperial trees -- was it, perhaps, by way of introduction from Kato-san? Per a review by Cheryl Owens of the book The Imperial Bonsai of Japan in the Fall 1977 issue of the Bonsai Journal, American Bonsai Society, pg. 66, in 1926 there were more than 5,000 bonsai in the possession of the Imperial Palace, compared with about 600 in 1976. 3 Busch's article, pp. 184-185, which on the former page states "That bonsai growing survived Japan's dark days during World War II must be credited almost entirely to Murata."; Tayson's article, pg. 13, which states that "only Murata San was allowed to continue as a bonsai entrepreneur, because he was the official entrusted to care for the Imperial Bonsai Collection."; Nippon Bonsai Association's Classic Bonsai of Japan (Tokyo: Kodansha International; 1989), pg. 154; Fukumoto, David W. "Saburo Kato: The Gentle Spirit of International Bonsai and Peace," Bonsai Journal, ABS, Vol. 22, No. 4, Winter 1988, pg. 6 states that the Katos at their Omiya nursery were criticized for taking care of bonsai during the war. 4 Busch's article, pp. 185-186. Where and when was Mercier's article[s] published? Our researches have not yet tracked it down. 5 Murata, Four Seasons, dustjacket notes; "Yuji Yoshimura: A Memorial Tribute To A Bonsai Master & Pioneer" by William N. Valavanis, International Bonsai, IBA, 1998/No. 1, pg. 31; Murata, Bonsai, pg. 115; Scholtz, Elizabeth "Japanese Beginnings at Brooklyn Botanic Garden," Bonsai Journal, ABS, Vol. 13, No. 1, Spring 1979, pp. 5-7. "In consultation with George S. Avery." 6 Perry, Lynn Bonsai, front biographical information; Bonsai Journal, ABS, Spring 1987, pg. 7; "History of Bonsai East" by Dorothy S. Young, International Bonsai Digest presents Bonsai Gems (Los Angeles: International Bonsai Digest, 1974), pp. 92; Per "The Catalyst" by Dorothy S. Young (Bonsai Journal, ABS, Vol. 8, No. 2, Summer 1974, pg. 40), Perry was introduced by Kaname Kato to Kyuzo Murata. Kaname Kato, "a quiet Japanese gentleman, a scholar, and horticulturist," was also the one who introduced Dr. John L. Creech to bonsai in 1955 during one of the latter's plant exploration travels to Asia. Creech, later as Director of the U.S. National Arboretum in Washington, D.C., subsequently worked to establish the National Bonsai Collection there, with Kato-san serving as an intermediary between Dr. Creech and the Japan Bonsai Society. Per personal e-mail correspondance between Dr. Creech and RJB on Nov. 26, 1999, Kaname Kato is not related toTomikichi (and Saburo, Hideo, et al) Kato. 7 Bonsai Journal, ABS, Vol. 1, No. 1, Spring 1967, pp. 3-5 and Summer 1987, pg. 6; Stowell, Jerald "People, Place, Plants, Revisted," Bonsai Journal, ABS, Vol. 23, No. 3, Fall 1989, pg. 10. 8 Bonsai Journal, ABS, Vol. 2, No. 2, pg. 19. 9 Avery, George S. "'Fudo' Comes to America," Bonsai Journal, ABS, Vol. 5, No. 1, Spring 1971, pp. 3-5. The cover is a b&w photo of the tree. The photo by the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, reproduced here, is from pg. 3 10 shows the lower foliage quote per Tayson's article, pg. 13; She departed quote per Kyuzo Murata in Bonsai Journal, ABS, Summer 1987, pg. 7. 11 Murata, "The Early Days" article, introduction, which also states Murata authored several Japanese texts and was "the advisor to several organizations and the Imperial Bonsai Collection." The latter seems to imply that he no longer was directly caring for those marvelous trees -- who was and what sort of apprenticeship program and/or "résumé" was required for that position? 12 Itinerary Brochure for this trip. In the spring of 1970, the first Japanese edition of the Japan Bonsai Society's Nippon Bonsai Taikan (Grand View of Japanese Bonsai and Nature in Four Seasons) was published. The ninety page English book, translated by Yuji Yoshimura and Samuel H. Beach and published in August 1972, included a small b&w photo of each original color one in the 352 page Japanese edition, along with a rendering of most of the text. On page 324 of the Japanese (pg. 81 of the English) can be found a picture of Kyuka-en. The conical thatched roof of the workshop behind the many orderly rows of bonsai catches one's eye. The edge of the roof is visible in the upper right corner of the first picture in Busch's article. A color photo of Kyuka-En with the modest caption "A view of a typical Japanese bonsai nursery" can be found on pp. 14-15 of Kawasumi's Bonsai with American Trees. 13 Stowell, Guide, pg. 83, and Murata's Foreword to on pg. 7; NY Times quote per "Kyuzo Murata in U.S.," Bonsai Journal, Vol. 9, No. 3, Fall 1975, pg. 64; Murata's address to ABS was reprinted as "Spirit of Bonsai," Bonsai Journal, Vol. 21, No. 2, Summer 1987, pp. 6-7; Bonsai, BCI, October 1975, pp. 256-257. Color photo from inside back cover of dust jacket of Kawasumi's Bonsai with American Trees. 14 Murata, "The Early Days" article, pg. 17 with b&w photo. 15 Murata, Four Seasons in Bonsai (Tokyo: Kodansha International Ltd.), dustjacket notes. 16 Bonsai Journal, ABS, Spring 1992, pg. 28. 17 "The Trees - Kate Bowditch" in "Books" by Max Braverman and Kate Bowditch, Bonsai Journal, ABS, Spring 1992, pg. 28. A review of Four Seasons in Bonsai, which also includes "The Pots - Max Braverman.". 18 Murata, Bonsai, Nature
in Miniature, dustjacket notes, which give the date of death as 1993.
No other reference to the son has yet been discovered. It is not
currently known by RJB as to how Kyuzo Murata was related -- if at all
-- to the prolific bonsai authors and editors Keiji and Kenji Murata.
|